Can You Cook A Frozen Pizza In A Toaster Oven?

Last updated on August 28th, 2022 at 11:44 pm

*This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

A toaster oven is a small countertop oven which can be put away out of sight when not in use. These little ovens have many benefits and they take up less space than a conventional oven although they essentially do the same thing. 

A toaster oven will fit on your countertop and can be put away when not in use, you can slide it back into the corner of your counter or even put it into a cupboard if you have room to place it there when it is not being used. Be sure to allow the toaster oven to cool completely before putting it away. 

Despite its name a toaster oven can do more than just toast, you can cook with it as well. Toaster ovens have a temperature range of 150 degrees Fahrenheit to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. If you want to be able to cook a variety of things in your toaster oven you can head to your local Walmart or shop online at Amazon to get smaller baking sheets, cake pans, pizza sheets, and more that are made to be used inside of a toaster oven. 

These smaller baking sheets and pans are the perfect size for a toaster oven. 

Toaster ovens do come in different sizes so be sure to see what size you have to see what size pan or casserole dish you can fit into your specific toaster oven model. Toaster ovens allow you to cook small batches of food without the energy cost that you would have running a conventional oven and without heating up your home as you would if using a conventional oven. 

You can bake small meals, cookies, cakes, breads, and more but what about frozen pizza? Can you cook it in your toaster oven?

You can cook frozen pizza in a toaster oven as long as the frozen pizza is small enough that it will fit.Pizzas are often cooked in toaster ovens and not only will they be cooked easily in one but they won’t heat up your entire house while doing it. 

The size of a pizza that you can fit into your toaster oven depends on the size of your toaster oven. You can cook your pizza directly on the rack or head to the store to get a smaller pizza pan that is designed to fit inside of a toaster oven. 

If you do not use a pan for your pizza the bottom crust of your pizza will be crispier. You will want to follow the directions on your frozen pizza if you are choosing to go the frozen pizza route. 

Some frozen pizzas will have directions for cooking in a toaster or convection oven as well as directions for a conventional oven. If the frozen pizza that you have does not contain toaster oven directions you can simply follow the directions that are printed for a conventional oven. 

You will just want to make sure that you check on your pizza a little sooner than you would in a conventional oven. Since the toaster oven is smaller than a conventional oven the food that you are preparing in it will be closer to the heating element and therefore might cook a little faster than it would in a conventional oven. 

It also can burn if you aren’t careful since it is so close to the heating elements so you should rotate your pizza at least once while it is cooking in a toaster oven. 

Perhaps you have leftover pizza from delivery the night before and you want to warm it up in the toaster oven. You can absolutely do this as well. Reheating your pizza in a toaster oven will crisp up your crust instead of causing it to become soggy as it can become in the microwave. 

Simply set your toaster oven to 425 degrees Fahrenheit and place your slice of pizza in it. Again, you can choose to set your pizza directly on the rack for a crispier crust or you can use a small pizza pan. If you want some gooey cheese on your pizza, you can spritz a little bit of water onto the cheese before popping it into the toaster oven as well. 

How Do I Make Pizza Crispy In A Toaster Oven?

You have some leftover pizza and want to warm it up but are wanting a crispy crust. If you cook pizza in a normal oven you can get a nice crispy crust but what about when cooking it in a toaster oven? 

To get a crispy pizza crust in a toaster oven you will want to put the pizza directly onto the rack. This will allow the crust to get more direct heat and in turn will get it crispier. 

Simply set your pizza in your toaster oven and turn it on to 425 degrees Fahrenheit for about 7 minutes. Once your 7 minutes is done you can switch your toaster oven over to broil for 2 to 3 minutes to really help your pizza crisp up. 

If you want a cheesier pizza, you can always add a little extra cheese to your slice of pizza before putting it into the toaster oven. You do not need to use a pan to set your slice of pizza on, you can place it directly on the toaster oven rack if you want your crust to be extra crispy. However, you will need to be sure to keep an eye on it so that the bottom of your crust does not burn.

How Long Does It Take A Toaster Oven To Preheat?

Toaster ovens are smaller than conventional ovens and sit on your countertop. Conventional ovens can take close to twenty minutes to preheat to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. Many people do not preheat their toaster ovens but if you are one who likes to have your food cooking at the optimal temperature the entire time it is cooking then you won’t have to wait as long for a toaster oven to preheat compared to how long you would be waiting for a conventional oven to preheat. 

The average toaster oven will take about 5 to 6 minutes to preheat to a temperature of 450 degrees Fahrenheit. This preheat time is a little less than half of what it would take for your conventional oven to reach the same temperature. 

If you have a toaster oven that has a LED screen the temperature of the toaster oven will be displayed on the screen so that you can see what the internal temperature of the toaster oven is so you will know exactly when to put your food in. 

What Can You Not Put In A Toaster Oven?

Toaster ovens are versatile kitchen appliances that can cook a wide range of foods. Not only can you bake things like cupcakes in a toaster oven but you can also make pizza or even bake chicken breasts. You can even bake bread in a toaster oven if you use a small sized bread pan. 

With all of this versatility, are there some things that you can not put into a toaster oven? 

There are two main things that you should not put into a toaster oven, parchment paper and glass bakeware (unless it is specifically designed to be used in a toaster oven). 

While parchment paper is designed to be used in ovens and to withstand extreme temperatures it can burn if it touches the heating elements. There is a risk of the parchment paper touching the heating elements in the small confinements of a toaster oven which could easily result in a fire. 

Glass bakeware should also be avoided in a toaster oven. Some glass dishes can shatter when put into a toaster oven from being too close to the heating elements. There is some glass bakeware that is designed to be used in toaster ovens so be sure and look the next time you are at the store if you want to use some of it in your toaster oven. 

Hannah R.

Hey, I'm Hannah and I'm the founder of Get Eatin'.

Recent Posts